Exactly one month ago I wrote about one of LUSH's latest online campaigns - 'Save Our Soaps'. Health and Safety Officials have banned bars of soap in public places, only allowing liquid soaps for public use. To me, this makes absolute sense, as on a personal hygiene level I would not want to share a bar with someone who I had never met or known, it can't harm me but it's just how I feel. I barely share a bar of soap with my family!
 |
Herbalife Herbal Aloe Bath & Body Bar: £6.40/125g (*)
The Bakewell Soap Co. English Lavender & Poppy Seeds Bar: £3.95/80g (*)
LUSH Rockstar: £3.40/100g
Dove Cream Body Bar: £0.79 |
However, the campaign got me thinking about liquid soap generally, is it necessary, has it taken over a classic bar of soap for nothing? Liquid soap has a larger carbon footprint than a bar of soap, it's generally more expensive and I find myself using a lot of it; so I embarked on a one month test to see if making the switch from liquid to bar soap really makes a difference at home. This is the story of how I got on.
WEEK ONE:
I began this challenge by switching from my liquid shower gel and liquid hand soap to a bar of soap only. I chose not to switch my liquid facial soap as I daren't play havoc with my already unsteady skin. My soaps of choice were LUSH Rockstar for my hands and Dove Cream Bar for my body.
By the end of week one my hands were feeling and looking very rough and the skin had begun to bubble and peel in places, I wondered if the LUSH soap was perhaps too strong for my hands but persisted to another week. The Dove Cream Body Bar left my body feeling wonderfully smooth and I noticed my underarms smelling particularly neutral and fresh. Using a bar of soap alone over my body proved time consuming, I found myself having to spend a couple more minutes in the shower to lather the soap and smooth it over my skin
WEEK TWO:
Mid way through week two my hands were feeling horrendously rough and the brutally honest people in my life were even pointing it out to me. They were flakey in areas too, which wasn't pleasant. I found myself needing to use hand cream at least three times a day on top of applying it after washing my hands, which became quite a nuisance when I wanted to wash my hands and go.
The Dove Body Bar was still going strong, but I began to miss having my deliciously scented shower gels and grew tired of spending an extra couple of minutes lathering a bar in the shower, it wasn't functional when I was in a rush. I hadn't noticed any difference between using a bar of soap and a liquid soap in the condition of the surface of my skin, so at the end of week two I switched back to my liquid shower gel, but kept the Dove Body Bar for use in places such as my underarms as I find shower gel is a little too harsh in areas such as these.
WEEK THREE:
At the start of week three my hands were in such terrible condition I stopped using the LUSH Soap, concluding it is too strong for my skin. Although it smells lovely and I use much less of it compared to liquid soap, what it was doing to my hands was really unpleasant to go through. I switched from the LUSH soap to Herbalife Bath & Body Bar. At this point I was no longer using a soap bar on my body except under my arms. I did trial the Herbalife bar on my body and it left it feeling wonderfully smooth, but again the time it took to use it in the shower wasn't practical for my schedule.
By the end of week three my hands were already looking better, I only needed to use hand cream twice a day and found the Herbalife soap a lot more gentle, it lathered much better too.
WEEK FOUR:
By week four I felt I had enough evidence to make grounded decisions about how I feel on the Liquid vs Bar soap debate, but persisted to the end. Through week four I used a mixture of Herbalife Bath & Body Bar and The Bakewell Soap Co Lavender and Poppyseeds bar, noticing a huge improvement in the condition of my hands again and enjoying the additional scented soap. Both these soaps lather well without compromising on natural ingredients, they left my hands feeling clean and I didn't need to apply any moisturiser after using them. I was still using Dove Cream Body Bar under my arms but did not use any bar soap on my body during week four.
It's been exactly one month since I began this challenge, and I've learnt a lot - I've even made changes to my bodycare routine because of it.
At the start of the challenge I had a 'normal' skin type, not dry, not oily - balanced. Over the month the skin on my hands began to switch from normal to very dry, but I am blaming this on the LUSH soap which I have since thrown away. I do now use a bar of soap instead of liquid soap to wash my hands because I use much less of it compared and it leaves my hands feeling squeaky clean. The LUSH bar has been replaced with Herbalife and The Bakewell Soap Co which I am now alternating between for variety. I am still suffering the effects of using a harsh soap on my hands, but they are improving every day.
Replacing shower gel with a bar of soap is not for me, the added two minutes spent rubbing the bar between my hands in the shower simply aren't practical when I'm in a rush. I saw no difference in the condition of my skin between the bar of soap and liquid soap. I am however using bar soap in sensitive areas such as my underarms as I notice they are left feeling a lot fresher. I'm also using the bar soap as a shaving cream under my arms and legs as it reduces resistance between the skin and the blade making for less redness and a smoother finish.
Using bars of soap instead of liquid soap has not saved me any money this past month as I have been experimenting with different soaps. In the future, switching to soap bars would cost me no more than £5 if I owned a separate soap for my hands and body and chose them wisely. They are lasting me much longer than my liquid soaps, so I conclude monthly and in the long run I will save money. I usually spend around £6 on shower gel and liquid soap each month alone, I would only need to spend the same amount every two or three months if I switched to bars.
I still would opt for liquid soaps in public places, and in the past month no advances have been made with LUSH's campaign.
Where do you stand on the Bar vs Liquid soap debate?